Pages

Tuesday, August 31, 2010

Catholics and Evolution

THE WALL STREET JOURNAL

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748703846604575447493644515142.html

AUGUST 27, 2010

Catholics and the Evolving Cosmos

By JOHN FARRELL

This month marks the 60th anniversary of the papal encyclical "Humani Generis," that laid out the Catholic Church's official relationship with Darwinian evolution. The pastoral letter, issued on Aug. 12, 1950 by Pope Pius XII, confirmed, in broad terms, that there is no intrinsic conflict between Christianity and the scientific theory of evolution. Considering that this was three years before the nature of DNA was even discovered, the pope's foresight in deciding to address the topic is remarkable.

Eugenio Pacelli, as Pius XII was known until his papacy, 1939-958, was the first pope to regard science and technology as subjects deserving their own encyclicals, or pastoral letters to Catholics world-wide.

For example, one of Pius's longest (and last) encyclicals, "Miranda Prorsus" ("Utterly Amazing," on Motion Pictures, Radio and Television), issued detailed guidelines on how Catholics in the entertainment industry should conduct themselves. In these days of downloadable pornography, and movies and music rife with sex and violence, the pope's enthusiasm for the positive social potential of entertainment, what he termed "food for the mind especially during the hours of rest and recreation," is touching.

In an ironic way the pope's hopeful attitude leaves one with a much stronger sense of dismay over how the industry has evolved—or devolved—than if he had simply issued a blanket condemnation of the media as a whole.

But it was another encyclical that earned Pius XII a chapter in the annals of the history of science. "Humani Generis" (Of the Human Race) laid out the Catholic Church's accommodation with Darwinian evolution—provided Christians believed the individual soul was not the product of purely material forces, but a direct creation by God.

This remains the position of the Catholic Church, one which was affirmed by the late Pope John Paul II in his celebrated 1996 address to the Pontifical Academy of Sciences. But if one reads Pius XII's encyclical today, especially in light of recent developments in genomics, it turns out the issue is more complicated.

While Pius was willing to concede that there was reason to believe the human body was the product of evolution, he was adamant that the special status of Adam as the father of the human race should not be a matter of question. "For the faithful," he wrote, "cannot embrace that opinion which maintains either that after Adam there existed on this earth true men who did not take their origin through natural generation from him as from the first parent of all or that Adam represents a certain number of first parents."

Pius declared that it was not apparent how such a theory of a founding population of humans, and not a single couple, could be reconciled with original sin. That Catholic doctrine regards the Fall as an historical rebellion against God; a sin actually committed by an individual and which is passed on through the generations from him to all men and women.

Subsequent research into genomics, however, has settled this question against Pius. It's not that scientists cannot trace human ancestry back far enough to an Adam and Eve; it's that in principle, the level of genetic variation present in the species today rules out a founding population with fewer than several thousand individuals.

A document drawn up for the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith in 2004, Communion and Stewardship, tacitly accepted the founding population theory of human origins. Communion and Stewardship was not widely publicized within the Catholic Church, and certainly did not make its way down to the pulpits for the general churchgoer in the way that an official encyclical would. And this raises the question of unfinished business when it comes to evolution and Christian theology.

For example, if the soul is to be considered a direct creation of God, distinct from the evolution of the human body, what does this tell us about its fundamental nature? Does the soul any longer have a nature, in the classic sense that medieval theologians inherited from Aristotle? Or is it to be understood in the more dualist terms of Descartes, a position previous popes have not approved? Should a future pope elaborate on this?

Certainly Catholic theologians have not been shy about addressing the questions that evolution raises for doctrines like original sin and the immateriality of the soul. In the 1960s, Jesuit theologian Karl Rahner re-interpreted Genesis in light of evolution, arguing that the story of Adam and Eve needed to be read metaphorically.

John Haught at Georgetown writes that the new cosmology of the expanding universe and the evolution of life require a more dynamic sense of God's role in a world that is still not complete, a work in progress. Father Denis Edwards at Flinders University in Australia treats the second person of the Trinity, the Holy Spirit, as a more active partner in the development of the evolving cosmos.

Whether the arguments of the theologians will move a future pope to broaden the Catholic Church's acceptance of evolution remains to be seen. So far, Pope Benedict XVI has not shown the same interest in evolution as his predecessor.

But on this 60th anniversary of "Humani Generis", Pius XII deserves credit for having the foresight to openly address the science when so many other denominations were either in deep denial or not interested in the challenge evolution poses for Christianity.

Mr. Farrell is the author of "The Day Without Yesterday: Lemaître, Einstein and the Birth of Modern Cosmology. " (Basic Books, 2006)

Copyright 2009 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved

19 comments:


  1. شركة نقل عفش بالمدينة المنورة 0557763091
    شركة نقل عفش بالمدينة المنورة التنقل من مكان لاخر ليس امرا سهلا بل امر يحتاج الى جهد كبير ووقت طويل كما ان اعمال النقل تحتاج الى احتراف فى ترتيب الاولويات وتنظيم العمل حتى لا يعرقل احد الاعمال عملا اخرا ويتسبب فى تأخر واخطاء، ومن هنا فقد نحتاج الى احد المتخصصين ليكونوا عونا لنا فى هذا العمل الشاق وتكون شركة نقل اثاث بالمدينة المنورة هى الاختيار الانسب لنا فى وقت الحاجة حيث الاتقان فى العمل وفن الترتيب والتنظيم بالاضافة الى الكفاءة فى اعمال النقل والقدرة على الانجاز
    لمزيد من خدماتنا
    شركة شراء اثاث مستعمل بالمدينة المنورة

    ReplyDelete
  2. 0728jejenike air flight huarache homme Les produits asics gel lyte femme argent sont résistants à l'eau et vous n'avez pas à basket air jordan adulte vous soucier de quelque chose. nike air jordan noir homme Pour tous ceux qui recherchent un nike internationalist femme rose pas cher peu plus de contrôle et de asics femme discount contrôle, les fers à repasser Nike Air Jordan 1 Baskets VR Pro donnent beaucoup plus de distance nike air max 90 leather pas cher et de pardon que les fers forgés. nike air max 1 essential femme noir et blanc

    ReplyDelete
  3. شركة التاج الملكي أرخص وأفضل وأكبر

    شركة تنظيف ابوظبى
    ، فتمتلك العديد من المقومات الرائعة التي تميزها عن غيرها من الشركات، حيث أن التنظيف يعتبر من الأمور الشاقة للغاية للمرأة خاصة إذا كانت المرأة تعمل فيكون ليس لديها وقت فارغ لتتم عملية التنظيف، حيث أن

    شركة تنظيف فى ابوظبى
    تمتلك عمالة مدربة على مستوى عالي من الجودة ولديهم خبرة تتعدي الخمس سنوات في مجال التنظيف، فالمرأة تكتشف البقع من بقايا المشروبات والطعام فلابد على أي مرأة أكتشافها لهذه البقع أن تقوم بالأتصال على الفور على

    شركة تنظيف مسابح ابوظبى
    ، حتى تعمل

    شركات تنظيف المنازل ابوظبى
    على تنظيف جميع الغرف والمطابخ والحمامات التي توجد في البيوت.

    تنظف فلل ابوظبى


    ماذا تقدم لعملائها
    تقدم

    شركة تنظيف شقق ابوظبى
    العديد من الخدمات والمميزات لعملائها حيث تعتبر من أفضل الشركات التي تعمل في مجال التنظيف، فتستخدم

    خدمات تنظيف ابوظبى
    العديد من المساحيق التي تعمل على إزالة البقع نهائياً.

    حيث تستخدم

    تنظيف منازل ابوظبى
    مساحيق خاصة لأزالة بقايا الطعام من المطابخ وخاصة السيراميك فالمطبخ لابد من تنظيفه جيداً وعدم أهماله حتى لا تتراكم الدهون والشحوم، كما أن المطبخ لابد من تعقيمه وترتيبه بأستمرار حتى لا يراكم الحشرات الزاحفة والطائرة وتعمل على تلوث الطعام وإصابة الإنسان بالأمراض.
    كما أن



    شركات تنظيف المنازل ابوظبى
    تعمل على خصم خدمة التنظيف لجميع العملاء، حيث أن

    شركات تنظيف المبانى ابوظبى
    تمتلك مهارة فائقة في مجال

    خدمات تنظيف ابوظبى

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks for the information, this is very useful. Allow me to share a health article here, which gods are beneficial to us. Thank you :)

    Solusi Tepat Pengobatan Kanker Nasofaring

    Cara Mengatasi Pengapuran Plasenta
    Pengobatan Alami Infeksi Telinga Tengah

    ReplyDelete

  5. فني ستلايت بالمدينة المنورة
    فني ستلايت بالمدينة المنورة يضيف لكم جميع القنوات المتميزة التي ترغب فيها ، فيضيف لكم القنوات الرياضية التي تحتاج الي باقة شهرية كبيرة فيقوم بمنحك تلك القنوات مجانا ، فالفني يقوموا بأداء الخدمة باحترافية فيقوم بتثبيت الطبق بشكل جيد منعا لعدم تلف القنوات ، يقوم بتركيب الطبق وضبط القنوات الفضائية وترتبها علي جهاز الرسيفر .

    ReplyDelete