Sunday, November 04, 2012

Tina Beattie, Disinvited Theologian, Defends her work


Tina Beattie, a London based academic theologian and a practicing, thinking, living, breathing, 21st century Catholic, was offered a fellowship and then disinvited by the University of San Diego. Here are her views in her own words and not (mis)interpreted by her critics
*************************************
   


TINA BEATTIE, PROFESSOR OF CATHOLIC STUDIES, UNIVERSITY OF ROEHAMPTON, LONDON: t.beattie@roehampton.ac.uk

It has come to my attention that some scurrilous accusations are being made about me by various Catholic bloggers. The allegations are based on serious distortions of my theological position through the publication of highly selective and decontextualized quotations from my work. I have no reason to hope that the people writing these blogs are willing to enter into the kind of informed theological debate that would reflect well on the Catholic community, and I think in general it is better to ignore them. They are a very small minority and they are held in contempt by many Catholics in this country. However, given that they seem intent on destroying my reputation as a theologian, I want to explain my position for those who are interested.

I am an academic theologian who is also a practising Catholic. (This is subtly different from claiming to be a Catholic theologian if that implies somebody with a licence who is authorised to teach by the official magisterium). I do not work in a Catholic university but in a College with Catholic foundations in a state-funded secular university. It is a unique and I believe precious feature of the British higher education system that theologians such as myself are given a space of academic freedom in which to pursue our vocations without interference from Church or state. Any academic theologian working in a university must follow Cardinal Newman’s advice of seeking to promote an intellectual culture in which reason rather than fideism is the basis for enquiry and research, knowing that in the Catholic tradition reason and revelation go hand in hand, and ‘grace perfects nature’. In other words, the probing use of reason should never be seen as the enemy of faith. It is a vital contribution that academic theologians make to the vitality and dynamism of Catholic life and culture, and it requires critical, robust and rigorous engagement with all intellectual resources.

However, I have always respected the difference between working in an academic context and working as a theological educator within the Catholic community. This is a difficult balance to maintain and I am not saying I always get it right, but I would never abuse the trust placed in me by bishops and other religious leaders, by using a platform in a church-based context to knowingly misrepresent the Church’s teachings or to mislead people about what these teachings are.

I have also always had absolute respect for the difference between the doctrinal truths of the faith, made knowable through revelation alone, and those truths which are arrived at by reason and which involve philosophical reflection informed by natural law and in engagement with other sources of human knowledge. So, with regard to all the doctrinal teachings that belong within the deposit of faith entrusted to the Church, my theological position is absolutely orthodox. Where I question some of the Church’s teachings, this is always to do with moral and social questions, informed by reason and natural law, which according to Catholic tradition must be argued in such a way that Catholics are able to enter into dialogue and debate with non-Catholics on questions of shared concern and practice.  I may have made many errors in the things I have written and said, but that is a risk that must be taken by anybody who engages in intellectual debate about complex ethical issues with an informed conscience. If I were questioning the doctrines of the Trinity, the Incarnation, the Real Presence, the Resurrection of the Body, the Virgin Birth, the Immaculate Conception or the Assumption, the CDF and the bishops would I believe have a right and a duty to point out my errors in a spirit of charity and good will. I have defended all these doctrines robustly in my theological publications. They are the grammar of the Catholic faith and knit our community together across the time and space of our historical existence, whatever our legitimate differences on social and moral issues.

In the Church’s dialogue with secular law and culture, the laity must be willing to engage in public debate in order to seek the most viable solution to complex ethical debates which affect non-Catholics as well as Catholics, and which require us to seek the common good in changing times and contexts. Of course there will be disagreements about this, but when Catholics handle such disagreements with intelligence and mutual respect, it can be a potent witness to the intellectual depth and diversity of our tradition. The bloggers publicly attacking me cause scandal by degrading this rich tradition in favour of a narrow and bigoted authoritarianism. I do not believe it serves the Catholic community well to present us as an entirely homogeneous group with neither the personal freedom nor the intellectual understanding to grapple with challenging social and ethical issues and to come to different positions about these.

I have been called pro-abortion in some recent blogs, and I find that deeply offensive. I am the mother of four children, and I am personally pro-life. I do not believe that there is any justification for the followers of Christ ever to endorse killing as a good or commendable act, whether it be abortion, war, capital punishment or euthanasia. However, there are serious issues that must be addressed with regard to how far the Church should use the law to defend positions which may not be defensible from the perspective of those who do not share the Christian faith. I have argued robustly against all late abortion, and I have written in detail about the serious abuses and violations which currently take place in Britain with regard to abortion. Many ‘pro-choice’ arguments put forward by secular feminists are morally repugnant and alienate those with a genuine concern for the sanctity and dignity of human life. It should be the aim of every Christian to work towards a world in which neither war nor abortion is necessary, while avoiding a dangerous utopianism which denies the complex and often tragic realities of human life. This means that a rightful concern to minimise the incidence of abortion must be balanced against the knowledge that nearly 70,000 of the world’s poorest women die every year as a result of illegal abortion, and many thousands more suffer serious long-term injury. Anyone who claims to be pro-life should be as concerned for the lives and well-being of these women as they are for their unborn children. These dilemmas are far more complex and anguished than either so-called pro-choice feminists or anti-abortion campaigners are willing to acknowledge. As a woman theologian who has personal experience of the joys and the struggles of pregnancy, childbirth and motherhood, I believe that I have a responsibility to reflect upon and address some of these issues. I find myself on the receiving end of profound hostility from both feminists and Catholic conservatives because of this.

The other claim that has been made against me recently is that “Tina Beattie mocks the Mass as an act of homosexual intercourse”, and that extracts from my work are “sacrilegious and deeply offensive”. This is pernicious. In the work that is cited and quoted by these bloggers, I was writing an extended critique of the theology of Hans Urs von Balthasar, whose writings I have studied for a number of years. My comments were made in the context of my deep concern over his highly sexualised representation of the Mass. This criticism is shared by a number of others who have written on von Balthasar. The suggestion that I mock the Mass because I criticise another theologian’s interpretation is outrageous.

I have also argued that there is theological justification for the ordination of women, and this is the one area in which I acknowledge that the arguments concern the sacramental tradition rooted in revelation, and not the natural law tradition rooted in reason. Ordination is not a right but a vocation which belongs within the sacramental mystery of the Church and which entails the gift of grace. However, my position on this is informed by the closest possible engagement with the Catholic sacramental and theological tradition. I am expressing views that are shared by many, many Catholics, including many priests and not a few bishops and cardinals. The teaching on women’s ordination is not infallible, and a papal commission appointed by Pope Paul VI found no decisive biblical teaching either in favour of or against women’s ordination. It is therefore possible for a theologian such as myself to explore the tradition with such questions in mind, although I recognize that the magisterium has tried to prohibit all such discussion.  

I would end with two quotations, from Catholics whose credentials are absolutely impeccable.


The Right Way To Suppress Error
(Pope John XXIII, Opening Address to the Second Vatican Council:
http://www.catholic-forum.com/saints/pope0261i.htm)


In these days, which mark the beginning of this Second Vatican Council, it is more obvious than ever before that the Lord's truth is indeed eternal. Human ideologies change. Successive generations give rise to varying errors, and these often vanish as quickly as they came, like mist before the sun.

The Church has always opposed these errors, and often condemned them with the utmost severity. Today, however, Christ's Bride prefers the balm of mercy to the arm of severity. She believes that, present needs are best served by explaining more fully the purport of her doctrines, rather than by publishing condemnations.

What do you do personally?

(Cardinal Martini, posthumously published interview http://www.indcatholicnews.com/news.php?viewStory=21013)

The Church has been left behind for 200 years. Why does she not shake? What are we afraid of? Fear instead of courage? However, the faith is the foundation of the Church. The faith, confidence, courage. I am old and sick, and I depend on the help of others. The good people around me make me feel the love. This love is stronger than the feeling of distrust that I sometimes perceive in to the Church in Europe. Only love conquers fatigue. God is Love. I still have a question for you: what you can do for the Church?

16 Comments:

Blogger Michelle said...

Thanks for posting this!

Sun Nov 04, 04:54:00 PM 2012  
Anonymous Benedict Jones said...

Tina dear, are these the scurrilous out of context quotes?

You have no else to blame but yourself!


In an examination of the morality of abortion Prof. Beattie justifies the argument that the embryo is not a person by using the doctrine of the Trinity. http://www.thetablet.co.uk/article/14789
Prof. Beattie uses the doctrine of the marriage between Christ and His Church to support gay marriage. http://www.thetablet.co.uk/article/162433
Prof Beattie condemns as ‘perverted’ a CTS booklet defending the Church’s doctrine on divorce and contraception.
http://www.thetablet.co.uk/blogs/355/17
Prof. Beattie describes the Mass as an ‘an act of (homo) sexual intercourse…’. ‘God’s Mother, Eve’s Advocate’, p.80.
Prof. Beattie supports government plans for same-sex marriage http://quehttp://www.thetablet.co.uk/latest-news/4459eringthechurch.com/2012/08/13/gay-marriage-catholic-diversity-expressed-in-england-and-wales/

Tue Nov 06, 05:35:00 PM 2012  
Anonymous Wayme Kirkby said...

To me, it seems quite right that Dr Bettie has been disinvited

Sun Nov 11, 11:25:00 AM 2012  
Anonymous JPIIamr said...

Dr. Beattie creates an undue distinction between the revealed doctrines of the Church such as The Trinity, the Incarnation, the Resurrection of the Body, the Virgin Birth, etc, and what she terms "moral and social questions informed by reason and natural law." She even claims that, "with regard to all the doctrinal teachings that belong within the deposit of faith entrusted to the Church, my theological position is absolutely orthodox." What she fails to see, however (and what makes her statement above false), is that there is no moral or social teaching of the Church that is not rooted in the Trinity and the Incarnation of Jesus Christ. As if homosexual marriage has nothing to do with the Incarnation or the Trinity! They have EVERYTHING to do with one another. That's the beauty of theology; one is led to see that Love bears a structure, bears an order of which form is the Trinity, and this informs every aspect of life, including marriage and the family, one's participation in civil society, and one's career. I am glad to see that she was disinvited by USD simply because she doesn't seem a very astute theologian. College students at Catholic universities deserve better than reactionary ideology.

Sat Dec 15, 12:11:00 PM 2012  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

You can do without the fellowship and they can do just as well without you in it. Theirs is the right to offer and withdraw it, yours now it is right to reflect.

Mon Dec 31, 09:32:00 AM 2012  
Blogger oakleyses said...

coach purses, louis vuitton handbags, kate spade outlet online, nike air max, michael kors outlet, michael kors outlet store, oakley sunglasses, burberry outlet online, coach outlet store online, michael kors outlet online, louis vuitton, louboutin shoes, louis vuitton outlet, louis vuitton outlet online, louis vuitton outlet, polo ralph lauren outlet, gucci handbags, oakley vault, longchamp handbags, polo ralph lauren, coach outlet, michael kors outlet online, tiffany and co jewelry, jordan shoes, burberry outlet online, ray ban outlet, nike air max, coach outlet, cheap oakley sunglasses, kate spade handbags, red bottom shoes, ray ban sunglasses, chanel handbags, christian louboutin shoes, nike free, tory burch outlet, christian louboutin outlet, nike shoes, prada handbags, tiffany jewelry, longchamp outlet, michael kors outlet online, prada outlet, longchamp outlet online, michael kors outlet online

Wed Oct 22, 10:20:00 PM 2014  
Blogger oakleyses said...

north face pas cher, louis vuitton pas cher, nike roshe run, hollister, barbour, ralph lauren pas cher, converse pas cher, nike air max, vans pas cher, nike air force, abercrombie and fitch, nike trainers, louis vuitton uk, true religion outlet, mulberry, sac louis vuitton, ray ban pas cher, nike huarache, nike free pas cher, michael kors canada, hollister, timberland, longchamp pas cher, hermes pas cher, sac vanessa bruno, air max, nike blazer pas cher, longchamp, ray ban uk, lacoste pas cher, michael kors uk, chaussure louboutin, air max pas cher, nike free, sac michael kors, louis vuitton, burberry pas cher, ralph lauren, nike roshe, air jordan, true religion outlet, new balance pas cher, lululemon, oakley pas cher, guess pas cher, nike air max, scarpe hogan, tn pas cher, north face, true religion

Wed Oct 22, 10:22:00 PM 2014  
Blogger oakleyses said...

babyliss pro, p90x workout, valentino shoes, canada goose pas cher, rolex watches, canada goose outlet, abercrombie and fitch, mcm handbags, lululemon outlet, canada goose outlet, new balance outlet, soccer shoes, bottega veneta, wedding dresses, insanity workout, hollister, canada goose, jimmy choo shoes, ugg outlet, ugg boots, north face outlet, uggs outlet, ghd, asics shoes, marc jacobs outlet, giuseppe zanotti, ferragamo shoes, longchamp, reebok outlet, birkin bag, north face jackets, canada goose uk, celine handbags, vans outlet, nfl jerseys, uggs on sale, ugg, moncler, mont blanc pens, roshe run, canada goose outlet, moncler outlet, mac cosmetics, chi flat iron, herve leger, beats headphones, moncler, ugg soldes, soccer jerseys, instyler ionic styler

Wed Oct 22, 10:23:00 PM 2014  
Blogger oakleyses said...

longchamp outlet online, burberry outlet online, michael kors outlet online, christian louboutin shoes, longchamp handbags, ray ban outlet, michael kors outlet online, louis vuitton outlet, oakley vault, chanel handbags, nike air max, louboutin shoes, kate spade handbags, prada handbags, louis vuitton handbags, coach outlet store online, kate spade outlet online, christian louboutin outlet, longchamp outlet, nike free, gucci handbags, louis vuitton outlet online, polo ralph lauren, louis vuitton outlet, oakley sunglasses, tiffany and co jewelry, michael kors outlet online, cheap oakley sunglasses, michael kors outlet, tiffany jewelry, burberry outlet online, ray ban sunglasses, coach outlet, louis vuitton, michael kors outlet online, prada outlet, coach purses, jordan shoes, nike shoes, tory burch outlet, nike air max, red bottom shoes, polo ralph lauren outlet, michael kors outlet store, coach outlet

Mon Oct 27, 10:49:00 PM 2014  
Blogger oakleyses said...

oakley pas cher, hollister, timberland, air max, nike roshe, true religion outlet, air max pas cher, sac vanessa bruno, ralph lauren pas cher, abercrombie and fitch, new balance pas cher, north face pas cher, chaussure louboutin, hollister, longchamp pas cher, hermes pas cher, nike roshe run, lululemon, barbour, nike air force, vans pas cher, air jordan, nike blazer pas cher, michael kors canada, nike air max, louis vuitton pas cher, ray ban pas cher, guess pas cher, nike free pas cher, louis vuitton uk, nike trainers, nike free, scarpe hogan, nike air max, true religion, longchamp, ray ban uk, north face, ralph lauren, sac louis vuitton, tn pas cher, converse pas cher, burberry pas cher, nike huarache, true religion outlet, louis vuitton, mulberry, sac michael kors, lacoste pas cher, michael kors uk

Mon Oct 27, 10:51:00 PM 2014  
Blogger oakleyses said...

insanity workout, mac cosmetics, vans outlet, ghd, moncler, moncler, wedding dresses, moncler outlet, abercrombie and fitch, jimmy choo shoes, north face outlet, instyler ionic styler, north face jackets, roshe run, canada goose pas cher, new balance outlet, uggs outlet, rolex watches, asics shoes, ugg outlet, soccer shoes, canada goose uk, herve leger, birkin bag, longchamp, canada goose, reebok shoes, canada goose outlet, valentino shoes, canada goose outlet, ferragamo shoes, nfl jerseys, uggs on sale, p90x workout, soccer jerseys, hollister, lululemon outlet, mcm handbags, ugg soldes, celine handbags, ugg boots, mont blanc pens, canada goose outlet, chi flat iron, bottega veneta, marc jacobs outlet, ugg, beats headphones, giuseppe zanotti, babyliss pro

Mon Oct 27, 10:54:00 PM 2014  
Blogger Wenhao Guo said...

winter coats, http://www.wintercoats.us.com/
canada goose jackets, http://www.canadagooseoutlet.com.co/
ugg outlet, http://www.uggoutlet.org.uk/
cyber monday deals, http://www.cybermondaydeals.in.net/
snow boots, http://www.snowboots.us.com/
canada goose outlet, http://www.canadagoose-coats.us.com/
canada goose outlet, http://www.canada-goosejackets.us.com/
canada goose jackets, http://www.canadagoosecanada.com/
ugg sale, http://www.uggsale.in.net/
canada goose jackets, http://www.canadagoosejackets.in.net/
winter jackets, http://www.winterjackets.us.com/
parajumpers coats, http://www.parajumpers.in.net/
discount ugg boots, http://www.discountuggboots.in.net/
canada goose jackets, http://www.canada-gooseoutlet.us.com/
cyber monday 2015, http://www.cybermonday2015.us.com/
ugg outlet, http://www.uggoutletstore.eu.com/
belstaff jackets, http://www.belstaff.us.com/
ugg boots, http://www.uggboots-outlet.co.uk/
wellensteyn jackets, http://www.wellensteyn.com.co/
black friday 2015, http://www.blackfriday2015.in.net/
ugg boots, http://www.uggbootscheap.eu.com/
barbour coats, http://www.barbour.us.com/
cheap ugg boots, http://www.cheapugg-boots.in.net/
woolrich outlet, http://www.woolrichoutletstore.us.com/
ugg outlet, http://www.uggoutlet.in.net/
moncler jackets, http://www.monclerjacketsuk.co.uk/
black friday deals, http://www.blackfridaydeals.us.com/
nobis outlet, http://www.nobis.us.com/
ugg australia, http://www.uggaustralia.in.net/
moncler outlet, http://www.moncleroutletstore.us.com/
achang1024

Fri Oct 23, 10:56:00 PM 2015  
Blogger 驴小布 said...

20151102 junda
louis vuitton
michael kors outlet online
canada gooses outlet
longchamp bags
true religion outlet
hermes uk
ralph lauren uk
mulberry bags
true religion jeans
canada gooses
ugg boots clearance
nike roshe run women
ralph lauren outlet
louis vuitton
juicy couture
nike store
ugg boots
christian louboutin uk
louis vuitton outlet
longchamp outlet
nike roshe runs
cheap oakley sunglasses
tory burch outlet
coach factory outlet
pandora charms
louis vuitton handbags
michael kors outlet
canada gooses jackets
coach outlet
jordan 6
michael kors outlet
jordan 4
louis vuitton outlet
mcm outlet
coach outlet
hollister uk
mont blanc pens
louis vuitton outlet
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet online

Mon Nov 02, 05:53:00 AM 2015  
Blogger chenlina said...

chenlina20151202
oakley sunglasses
cheap uggs
louis vuitton outlet
replica watches
coach outlet
christian louboutin outlet
jordans for sale
ugg outlet
canada goose outlet
hollister co,hollister jeans,hollister.com,hollister ca
uggs on sale
nike air max
oakley sunglasses
michael kors handbags
canada goose outlet online
louis vuitton
cheap ugg boots
oakley sunglasses
swarovski outlet
louis vuitton
michael kors outlet
kids uggs on sale
michael kors handbags
ugg boots
gucci shoes
cheap uggs for sale
michael kors outlet online
ugg boots
oakley sunglasses cheap
christian louboutin shoes
the north face outlet
michael kors outlet
air max 95
longchamp outlet
coach factory outlet
michael kors outlet
louis vuitton handbags
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet
cheap air jordans
as

Wed Dec 02, 02:08:00 AM 2015  
Blogger chenlina said...

chenlina20151209
ugg boots
coach outlet
abercrombie kids
toms shoes
louis vuitton outlet online
michael kors outlet
gucci shoes
hollister co
coach factory outlet
michael kors outlet online
michael kors outlet online
canada goose jackets
uggs for men
coach factory outlet
canada goose outlet
air force 1
fake oakley sunglasses
timberland outlet
michael kors outlet
ugg outlet
louis vuitton handbags
michael kors outlet
ed hardy clothing
louis vuitton handbags
louis vuitton
prada handbags
cheap uggs
ray ban sunglasses
michaek kors outlet
oakley sunglasses
hollister uk
ralph lauren outlet
ray ban sunglasses
nike air max
cheap ugg boots
true religion outlet
michael kors outlet online
polo ralph lauren outlet
uggs outlet
ray ban sunglasses outlet
as

Wed Dec 09, 12:27:00 AM 2015  
Blogger Nike Free said...

michael kors purses
michael kors handbags
michael kors bags
michael kors tote
michael kors uk
macys michael kors
michael kors factory
michael kors outlets
michael kors outlet online store 49.00 outlet
Michael Kors Flagship Store
Cheap Michael Kors Bags
Michael Kors Handbags
Michael Kors Jewelry
Michael Kors Purses,Michael Kors Wallet,Cheap Michael Kors Purses
Michael Kors Clutches
Michael kors Jet Set
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet stores
2015 michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet online sale
michael kors outlet online
michael kors sale
michael kors sale

Wed Dec 30, 11:54:00 PM 2015  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home