A Jesuit's Jottings
Rick Malloy, S.J., is a Jesuit priest and cultural anthropologist. He is the author of _A Faith That Frees: Catholic Matters for the 21st Century (2007) and _Being on Fire: The Top Ten Essentials of Catholicism_ (2014), both published by ORBIS Books
Thursday, January 02, 2025
Sunday, December 22, 2024
Jon Stewart's explanation on
corporate trickle down.
“When
corporations fail you pay for it. But when they succeed, it’s theirs. They socialize their losses and privatize
their gains. Why do we allow that?
[Voice
of an apologist for Capitalism on cable news] “Consider this wealthy people do
not stash their billions in safe deposit boxes loaded with $100 bills. They don’t
do that and they don’t spend it all at the mall. They don’t spend like crazy. No
wealthy people invest. It is investment that creates jobs and economic growth.”]
See
this is the lie they tell you. That all this money flowing towards corporate
moneyed interests is actually for your benefit. That government intervention
for corporations is our free market, but government intervention for workers is
socialism. And that’s the reason for all the socialism scaremongering. It’s a
false choice to make you believe that this country has but two options: a
socialist, authoritarian, hamburgerless, Venezuelan nightmare, or accept the
status quo where large corporations benefit from government help, then use some
of those profits to lobby the same government for more government help.
They
want you to believe that in the free market, while your wages stay low, someday
the largesse will eventually trickle down. And in the meantime, enjoy watching
your tax dollars help billionaires launch themselves into ******* space.”
(“Jon
Stewart's explanation on corporate trickle down.”
Bing Videos. Accessed Dec 22, 2024)
Friday, November 08, 2024
Heather Cox Richardson (2023) Democracy Awakening: Notes on the State of America (Viking), p. xii-xiii.
“The key to the rise of authoritarians… is their use
of language and false history
Authoritarians rise when economic, social, political,
or religious change makes members of a formerly powerful group feel as if they
have been left behind. Their frustration makes them vulnerable to leaders who
promise to make them dominant again. A strongman downplays the real conditions
that have created their problems and tells them that the only reason they have
been dispossessed is that their enemies have cheated them of power.
Such leaders undermine existing power structures, and
as they collapse, people previously apathetic about politics turn into
activists, not necessarily expecting a better life, but seeing themselves as
heroes reclaiming their country. Leaders don’t try to persuade people to
support real solutions, but instead reinforce their followers’ fantasy
self-image and organize themselves into a mass movement. Once people
internalize their leader’s propaganda, it doesn't matter when pieces of it are
proven to be lies, because it has because become central to their identity
As a strong man becomes more and more destructive,
followers’ loyalty only increases. Having begun to treat their perceived
enemies badly, they need to believe their victims deserve it. Turning against
the leader who inspired such behavior would mean admitting they had been wrong
and that they, not their enemies, are evil. This they cannot do.
Having forged a dedicated following, a strongman warps history to galvanize his base into an authoritarian movement. He insists that his policies – which opponents loathe – simply follow established natural or religious rules his enemies have abandoned. Those rules portray society as based in hierarchies, rather than equality, and make the strongman's followers better than their opponents. Following those “traditional” rules creates a clear path for a nation and can only lead to a good outcome. Failing to follow them will lead to terrible consequences.”
Monday, December 18, 2023
Mary Did You Know (Lyrics bt Jennifer Hardy)
Fr. Malloy’s Midweek Message. December 20, 2023
Read Mary’s
Magnificat, Luke 1:46-55.
This is prayed every evening in the Church’s Liturgy of the Hours.
Friends,
Mary’s song
sung at the beginning of Luke’s Gospel is a powerful prayer that proclaims the
“Greatness of the Lord.” Mary rejoices
in all the God is doing for the salvation of the world and all the peoples of
this planet. God has mercy. He cares for the poor and sends “the rich
away empty.”
Jennifer
Hardy has rewritten the words to the popular Christmas Song, “Mary Did You
Know.” (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O_pae1ZfxWw ). Hardy’s lyrics
poetically parallel Mary’s Magnificat.
Mary Did you Know?
Mary did you know, that your ancient words would still leap
off our pages?
Mary did you know, that your spirit song would echo through
the ages?
Did you know that your holy cry would be subversive word,
that the tyrants would be trembling when they know your truth
is heard?
Mary did you know, that your lullaby would stir your own
Child’s passion?
Mary did you know, that your song inspires the work of
liberation?
Did you know that your Jubilee is hope within the heart
of all who dream of justice, who yearn for it to start?
The truth will teach, the drum will sound, healing for the
pain
The poor will rise, the rich will fall. Hope will live again
Mary did you know, that we hear your voice for the healing of
the nations?
Mary did you know, your unsettling cry can help renew
creation?
Do you know, that we need your faith, the confidence of you,
May the God that you believe in, be so true.
Lyrics by Jennifer Henry (inspired by the popular song of the
same name) Mary did you know? – Rewrite! – SCM Canada
On behalf of
Cristo Rey Jesuit, I wish you all a Wonderful (full of wonder), peaceful, Merry
Christmas.
Peace,
Fr. Rick
Malloy, S.J.
Keep
Safe. Keep Sane. Keep Smiling
El Miercoles Mensaje del
Padre Malloy, S.J. 20 de Diciembre,
2023
Lee el Magnificat de María,
Lucas 1, 46-55.
Se reza todas las tardes en la Liturgia de las Horas de la Iglesia.
Amigos y Amigas
El canto de María al comienzo del Evangelio de Lucas es una poderosa oración que proclama la "Grandeza del Señor". María se alegra de todo lo que Dios está haciendo por la salvación del mundo y de todos los pueblos de este planeta. Dios tiene misericordia. Cuida de los pobres y despide "a los ricos con las manos vacías".
Jennifer Hardy ha
reescrito la letra de la popular canción navideña "Mary Did You Know"
(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O_pae1ZfxWw).
La letra de Jennifer Hardy hace un paralelo poético con el Magnificat de
María.
¿Sabías,
María?
¿Sabías, María, que tus antiguas palabras
aún saltarían de nuestras páginas?
¿Sabías, María, que tu canto espiritual
resonaría a través de los siglos?
¿Sabías que tu grito santo sería palabra
subversiva
que los tiranos temblarían al saber que tu
verdad es escuchada?
¿Sabías, María, que tu canción de cuna
despertaría la pasión de tu propio Hijo?
¿Sabías, María, que tu canto inspira la
obra de la liberación?
¿Sabías que tu Jubileo es esperanza en el
corazón
de todos los que sueñan con la justicia,
que anhelan que comience?
La verdad enseñará, el tambor sonará,
curación para el dolor
Los pobres se levantarán, los ricos caerán.
La esperanza volverá a vivir
María ¿sabías, que oímos tu voz para la
curación de las naciones?
María ¿sabías, que tu grito inquietante
puede ayudar a renovar la creación?
¿Sabes que necesitamos tu fe, tu confianza?
Que el Dios en el que crees, sea tan
verdadero.
Letra de Jennifer Henry (inspirada en la
popular canción del mismo nombre) Mary did you know? - Mary did you know? –
Rewrite! – SCM Canada
En nombre de Cristo Rey Jesuita, les deseo
a todos una Maravillosa (llena de asombro), pacífica, Feliz Navidad.
La Paz,
P. Ricardo Malloy, S.J.
Sigamos Seguro. Sigamos Sano. Sigamos Sonriendo
Monday, December 04, 2023
ADVENT: Prayer is the answer
ADVENT PRAYER
“Spiritually we seem to be in an
enormous vacuum. Humanly speaking there
is the same burning question - what is the point of it all? And in the end, even that question sticks in
one’s throat. Scarcely anyone can see or
even guess at, the connection between the corpse-strewn battlefields, the heaps
of rubble we live in and the collapse of the spiritual cosmos of our views and
principles, the tattered residue of our moral and religious convictions as
revealed by our behavior. And even if
the connection were fully understood it would be only a matter for academic
interest, data to be noted and listed.
No one would be shocked or deduce from the facts a need for reformation.”
- from The Prison Meditations of Alfred
Delp, S.J. Fr. Delp was executed by
the Nazis Feb. 2, 1945.
Sometime during Advent, see if you can find Paradise Road. This movie about a group of women held in concentration camps by the Japanese during WWII is an extraordinary story of human courage, care and compassion. It shows how even the simplest practices of beauty and art (in Paradise Road the formation of a human voice orchestra) can counter and transform even the most horrific situations, and counter the most bestial acts humans can perpetrate against one another. Like those abused and mistreated women, we also are called to be human and loving in a too often brutalizing and bruised world.
If I told you that doing “X,” one simple practice, will guarantee that you do better in confronting the insanities of ours and every age, will help you feel less stressed out throughout December, and actually appreciate, even enjoy, life in our days, despite all the problems and pain, would you want to know what “X” is? You already do. It is prayer.
The answer is prayer, that simple yet difficult practice of paying attention to God. Prayer is a way of allowing God to grace us with inner harmony and outer peace. Prayer is a practice that helps us reach our heart’s deepest and truest desires: our heartfelt search for meaning, and our ultimate origin and destiny, i.e., God. Prayer is that discipline of slowing down, breathing, getting quiet, feeling the rhythms of life, and touching (and being touched back by) our infinite source of joy and jubilation, respect and renewal, hope and healing: the Lord of love and life. Prayer is looking at Jesus, contemplating what the Gospels tell us of him, and paying attention to what the Risen Christ present and active in our lives is doing here, now, today! Prayer is sacraments and singing, loving and listening, inspiring and imagining. Prayer is an evermore fascinating adventure, the most challenging task in life, and the most incredible experience available to us.
So why don’t we pray? We live in a time that finds belief in God difficult. We have seen the past century knee deep in blood and know the violence of our times. Murder rates are down in Baltimore and other places, but still way too high. We have felt, deep down in our dark, quiet nights, the fear and fragility of being a mere human being. We don’t pray because slowing down and listening brings us face to face with the difficulties and dangers of our human experience.
Advent is for people who have felt the need of a God who cares, a God who will come to us in our weakness and save us. Advent is a time of waiting, a time to wait anxiously and see if the dark days stop getting shorter and once again increase in light. Fr. Alfred Delp and The women in Paradise Road knew this waiting. Advent is a time to know that God comes to us as we are, in all our confusion and chaos, tragedy and tension. Truth be told, God comes to us in our stale, stinking, sinful condition.
“Unless a man has been shocked to
his depths at himself and the things he is capable of, as well as the failings
of humanity as a whole, he cannot understand the full import of Advent.” -
Alfred Delp, S.J.
Thomas Merton, writing in an introduction to Fr. Delp's prison meditations, notes, "In effect, the temptation to negativism and irrationality, the urge to succumb to pure pragmatism and the massive use of power, is almost overwhelming in our day."
Our times can tempt us to prostitute ourselves to pure pragmatism and block out the deep and haunting questions of human existence. But such blocking out also will dampen and extinguish the ability to feel exhilaration and joy. Then we can sink into negativity and irrationality. Still, the practice of prayer will keep us from being overwhelmed and open us to the grace of sanity.
Advent Prayer is waiting prayer. If we wait attentively, we will feel less stress, less pain, less lack of purpose. As we pray, we can begin to feel the quickening of hope in our and the whole world’s soul. Sitting in a church chapel 15 to 30 minutes a day, reading the Bible each night before sleeping, going to daily Mass, praying a rosary daily, or reading a good spiritual book, will give us inner strength, and energize us for the tasks ahead. Life will be seen more as promise and possibility deep within the paradoxes. Once again God will be born: in our hearts, through our prayer.
Have a Blessed Advent Season.
Tuesday, June 06, 2023
Fr. Malloy’s Midweek Message. June 6, 2023
Friends,
This
Sunday we celebrate the Feast of the Body and Blood of Christ. Along with
Pentecost and the Feast of the Holy Trinity, this focus on the Eucharist
plunges us into the central mystery of our faith: Our
God is an incarnate God, a God with and for us. In Jesus, God takes on human flesh, human
reality. Our God is as real as the heart
pumping in each of us. Our God is as
real as the food we eat every day. Our
God feeds us as the Israelites were fed with manna in the desert.
In our
celebration of the Eucharist, the Mass, Jesus is really, substantially, present
in four ways. In the community gathered, in the Word proclaimed, in
the person of the priest, and in the consecrated bread and wine. In this work of the people, the liturgy, the
sacrifice of Jesus on the cross continues to save and transform us.
One person, bemoaning
the fact that so many take the Eucharist for granted and show little response
to this great gift and mystery, challengingly asks, “What if the bread and wine
change, but we don’t?” The grace of
Eucharist transforms us in Christ to become his body in the world today. In John’s Gospel, Jesus proclaims:
“I am
the bread of life. … I am the living
bread that came down from heaven; whoever eats this bread will live forever;
and the bread that I will give is my flesh for the life of the world.” The Jews quarreled among
themselves, saying, “How can this man give us [his] flesh to eat?” Jesus said to them,
“Amen, amen, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of
the Son of Man and drink his blood, you do not have life within you. Whoever eats my flesh
and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him on the last day. For my flesh is true
food, and my blood is true drink. Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood
remains in me and I in him. …
Then many of his disciples who were listening said, “This saying is hard; who can accept it?”
Since Jesus knew that his disciples were murmuring about this, he said
to them, “Does this shock you? What if you were to see the Son of Man
ascending to where he was before? It is the spirit that gives life, while the flesh is of no
avail. The words I have spoken to you are spirit and life.
But there are some of you who do not
believe.” …
As a result
of this, many [of] his disciples returned to their former way of life and no
longer accompanied him.
Jesus then said to the Twelve, “Do you also want to leave?” Simon Peter answered
him, “Master, to whom shall we go? You have the words of eternal life. We have come to
believe and are convinced that you are the Holy One of God.” (John 6)
Our praying the
Eucharist sends us forth to transform our world. Many find it difficult to accept the
challenge of this teaching. So it was in
Jesus’ time. So it is in ours. Let’s ask God to help us receive the
Eucharist in ways that truly transform us.
The Eucharist makes us disciples who are Happy and Healthy and Holy and
Free.
Peace,
Fr. Rick Malloy, S.J.
Keep Safe.
Keep Sane. Keep Smiling
Fiesta del Cuerpo y la Sangre de Cristo
El Miercoles Mensaje del Padre Malloy, S.J. 6 de Junio, 2023
Amigos
y Amigas,
Este domingo celebramos la
Fiesta del Cuerpo y la Sangre de Cristo. Junto con Pentecostés y la fiesta de la
Santísima Trinidad, esta concentración en la Eucaristía nos sumerge en el
misterio central de nuestra fe: Nuestro Dios es un Dios
encarnado, un Dios con y para nosotros. En Jesús, Dios toma carne humana, realidad
humana. Nuestro Dios es tan real como el
corazón que late en cada uno de nosotros.
Nuestro Dios es tan real como los alimentos que comemos cada día. Nuestro Dios nos alimenta como los israelitas
fueron alimentados con el maná en el desierto.
En nuestra celebración de
la Eucaristía, la Misa, Jesús está real, sustancialmente, presente de cuatro
maneras. En la comunidad reunida,
en la Palabra proclamada, en la persona del sacerdote y en el pan y el vino
consagrados. En esta obra del pueblo, la
liturgia, el sacrificio de Jesús en la cruz sigue salvándonos y
transformándonos.
Una persona,
lamentando el hecho de que tantos den por sentada la Eucaristía y muestren poca
respuesta a este gran don y misterio, pregunta desafiante: "¿Y si el pan y
el vino cambian, pero nosotros no?".
La gracia de la Eucaristía nos transforma en Cristo para convertirnos en
su cuerpo en el mundo de hoy. En el
Evangelio de Juan, Jesús proclama:
"Yo soy el pan de vida. ... Yo soy el pan vivo bajado del cielo; el
que coma de este pan vivirá para siempre; y el pan que yo daré es mi carne para
la vida del mundo". Los judíos
discutían entre sí, diciendo: "¿Cómo puede éste darnos [su] carne a
comer?". Jesús les dijo: "En verdad, en verdad los
digo: si no comen la carne del Hijo del hombre y no beben su sangre, no tendrán vida en vosotros. El que come mi carne y bebe mi sangre tiene
vida eterna, y yo lo resucitaré en el último día. Porque mi carne es verdadera comida y mi
sangre es verdadera bebida. El que come
mi carne y bebe mi sangre permanece en mí y yo en él. ...
Entonces muchos de sus discípulos que estaban
escuchando dijeron: "Esta palabra es dura; ¿quién puede aceptarla?". Como Jesús
sabía que sus discípulos murmuraban de esto, les dijo: "¿Los escandaliza
esto? ¿Y si vieran al Hijo del hombre
subir a donde estaba antes? Es el
espíritu el que da vida, mientras que la carne no sirve para nada. Las palabras
que los he hablado son espíritu y vida.
Pero hay algunos de Uds. que no creen". ...
A raíz de esto, muchos de
sus discípulos volvieron a su antiguo estilo de vida y dejaron de
acompañarle. Jesús dijo entonces a los
Doce: "¿También Uds. quieren marcharse?". Simón Pedro le respondió: "Maestro, ¿a
quién vamos a ir? Tú tienes palabras de vida eterna. Hemos llegado a creer y estamos convencidos
de que tú eres el Santo de Dios". (Juan 6)
Rezar la Eucaristía
nos envía a transformar nuestro mundo. A
muchos les cuesta aceptar el desafío de esta enseñanza. Así fue en tiempos de Jesús. También en la nuestra. Pidamos a Dios que nos ayude a recibir la
Eucaristía de manera que realmente nos transforme. La Eucaristía nos hace discípulos felices,
sanos, santos y libres.
La
Paz,
P.
Ricardo Malloy, S.J.
Sigamos Seguro.
Sigamos Sano. Sigamos Sonriendo
Wednesday, May 31, 2023
Become Poverty Abolitionists
Fr.
Malloy’s Midweek Message. May 31, 2023
Friends,
Today
is the Feast of the Visitation. We
remember that immediately after the angel tells Mary she will be the mother of
the savior, Mary goes in haste to visit Elizabeth. Mary soon bursts into the Magnificat, the
canticle in which she proclaims, “God has cast down
the mighty from their thrones and has lifted up the lowly. He has filled the hungry with good things and
the rich he has sent away empty” (Luke 1:52-53). When Jesus comes among us, everything gets
shaken up and transformed, including our political economy.
Too
many accept without critique the ideals of neoliberal economic thought: Government should leave markets alone to make
the world in which we live; profits for shareholders are primary while the
needs of workers and the community matter less and less; corporations are not
to be held accountable for the costs of pollution to the planet. In contradiction to Catholic Social Teaching, neoliberal economics holds that human
persons are greedy and self-interested, and everyone fighting in a dog eat dog
world is the best we can do
Matthew
Desmond, a sociologist at Princeton, in his new book Poverty by America,
challenges the assumptions surrounding much of our thinking about poverty, the
poor, and the ways we structure our political economy. He argues we have so many poor people in the
United States because we allow it and want this situation to continue. Many of
us benefit off of low wages and subsidies that help the rich, while failing to
demand public policies that would eliminate poverty among us. He prophetically
and provocatively calls for us to become Poverty Abolitionists. Here
are some excerpts from a NY Times article Desmond published March 9, 2023.
Excerpts
from Matthew Desmond “Why Poverty Persists in America”
(NYTimes. March 9, 2023) Why Poverty Persists in America - The New York Times
(nytimes.com)
“We’ve approached the poverty question by pointing to poor
people themselves, when we should have been focusing on exploitation.”
“12.6
percent of the U.S. population was poor in 1970; two decades later, it was 13.5
percent; in 2010, it was 15.1 percent; and in 2019, it was 10.5 percent.” [In 2021 it was 11.6% (source https://www.census.gov/newsroom/stories/poverty-awareness-month.html). That’s some 39 million people. That’s equal to the population of California
- addition by Malloy].
“…
[LBJ’s] first five years in office, a breathtaking level of activity. And the
result? Ten years after the first of these programs were rolled out in 1964,
the share of Americans living in poverty was half what it was in 1960.”
“…
cellphones have become more affordable over the past few decades, and now most
Americans have one, including many poor people. This has led … senior fellows
at the Brookings Institution, to assert that “access to certain consumer
goods,” like TVs, microwave ovens and cellphones, shows that “the poor are not
quite so poor after all.”
No, it doesn’t. You can’t eat a cellphone. A cellphone doesn’t
grant you stable housing, affordable medical and dental care or adequate child
care. In fact, as things like cellphones have become cheaper, the cost of
the most necessary of life’s necessities, like health care and rent, has
increased. From 2000 to 2022 in the average American city, the cost of fuel
and utilities increased by 115 percent. The American poor, living as they do in
the center of global capitalism, have access to cheap, mass-produced goods, as
every American does. But that doesn’t mean they can access what matters most.
As Michael Harrington put it 60 years ago: “It is much easier in the United
States to be decently dressed than it is to be decently housed, fed or
doctored.”
Reagan
expanded corporate power, deeply cut taxes on the rich and rolled
back spending on some antipoverty initiatives, especially in housing. But he was
unable to make large-scale, long-term cuts to many of the programs that make up
the American welfare state. … There is no evidence that the United States
has become stingier over time. The opposite is true. This makes the
country’s stalled progress on poverty even more baffling. Decade
after decade, the poverty rate has remained flat even as federal relief has
surged.
If
we have more than doubled government spending on poverty and achieved so
little, one reason is that the American welfare state is a leaky bucket.
Take welfare, for example: … [With
the1996 reform] Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF), [President
Clinton] transformed the program into a block grant that gives states
considerable leeway in deciding how to distribute the money. As a result,
states have come up with rather creative ways to spend TANF dollars. Arizona
has used welfare money to pay for abstinence-only sex education. Pennsylvania diverted
TANF funds to anti-abortion crisis-pregnancy centers. Maine used the money to
support a Christian summer camp. Nationwide, for every dollar budgeted for TANF in 2020,
poor families directly received just 22 cents.
“There
are, it would seem, deeper structural forces at play, ones that have to do with
the way the American poor are routinely taken advantage of. The primary reason
for our stalled progress on poverty reduction has to do with the fact that we
have not confronted the unrelenting exploitation of the poor in the labor,
housing and financial markets.”
“…long
history of slum exploitation in America. Money made slums because slums made
money. Rent has more than doubled over the past two decades,
rising much faster than renters’ incomes. Median rent rose from $483 in 2000 to
$1,216 in 2021.”
“According
to the F.D.I.C., one in 19 U.S. households had no bank account in 2019, amounting
to more than seven million families. Compared with white families, Black and
Hispanic families were nearly five times as likely to lack a bank account.
Where there is exclusion, there is exploitation. Unbanked Americans have
created a market, and thousands of check-cashing outlets now serve that market.
Check-cashing stores generally charge from 1 to 10 percent of the total,
depending on the type of check.”
“[A
novel] describe[s] the problem of suicides on Native American
reservations says: “Kids are jumping out the windows
of burning buildings, falling to their deaths. And we think the problem is that
they’re jumping.” The poverty debate
has suffered from a similar kind of myopia. For the past half-century, we’ve
approached the poverty question by pointing to poor people themselves — posing
questions about their work ethic, say, or their welfare benefits — when we
should have been focusing on the fire. The question
that should serve as a looping incantation, the one we should ask every time we
drive past a tent encampment, those tarped American slums smelling of asphalt
and bodies, or every time we see someone asleep on the bus, slumped over in
work clothes, is simply: Who benefits? Not:
Why don’t you find a better job? Or: Why don’t you move? Or: Why don’t you stop taking out
payday loans? But: Who is feeding off this?”
Jesus
said “The poor you will always have with you” to Judas (John 12:4-5). People like Judas keep people in
poverty. Jesus wants us to free everyone
from all the enslaves and diminishes our flourishing as human beings and
community. Let’s read Desmond’s book and
let’s join together to eradicate poverty in our world.
Peace,
Fr. Rick
Malloy, S.J.
Keep
Safe. Keep Sane. Keep Smiling
Convertirse
en abolicionistas de la pobreza
El
Miercoles Mensaje del Padre Malloy, S.J.
31 de Mayo, 2023
Amigos y Amigas,
Hoy es la fiesta de la Visitación. Recordamos que, inmediatamente después de que
el ángel le dijera a María que sería la madre del Salvador, María se apresuró a
visitar a Isabel. Pronto prorrumpe en el
Magnificat, cántico en el que proclama: "Dios
ha derribado del trono a los poderosos y ha enaltecido a los humildes. A los hambrientos los sació de bienes y a los
ricos los despidió vacíos" (Lucas 1,
52-53). Cuando Jesús viene entre
nosotros, todo se sacude y se transforma, incluida nuestra economía política.
Demasiados aceptan sin crítica los ideales del pensamiento
económico neoliberal: El gobierno debe
dejar que los mercados hagan solos el mundo en que vivimos; los beneficios para
los accionistas son primordiales, mientras que las necesidades de los
trabajadores y de la comunidad importan cada vez menos; las empresas no deben
responder de los costes de la contaminación del planeta. En contradicción con la
doctrina social católica, la economía
neoliberal sostiene que los seres humanos son codiciosos y egoístas, y que lo
mejor que podemos hacer es luchar todos contra todos en un mundo donde el perro
se come al perro.
Matthew Desmond, sociólogo de Princeton, en su nuevo libro
Poverty by America, cuestiona los supuestos que rodean gran parte de nuestro
pensamiento sobre la pobreza, los pobres y las formas en que estructuramos
nuestra economía política. Sostiene que
tenemos tantos pobres en Estados Unidos porque lo permitimos y queremos que
esta situación continúe. Muchos de nosotros nos beneficiamos de los bajos
salarios y de las subvenciones que ayudan a los ricos, mientras que no exigimos
políticas públicas que eliminen la pobreza entre nosotros. De manera profética y
provocadora, nos llama a convertirnos en Abolicionistas de la Pobreza. He aquí algunos extractos de un artículo del NY Times que
Desmond publicó el 9 de marzo de 2023.
Extractos de Matthew Desmond "Por qué
persiste la pobreza en América"
(NYTimes. 9 de marzo de 2023) Why Poverty Persists in America - The New York Times
(nytimes.com)
"Hemos abordado la cuestión de la pobreza señalando a los
propios pobres, cuando deberíamos habernos centrado en la explotación".
"El 12,6 por ciento de la población estadounidense era
pobre en 1970; dos décadas después, era el 13,5 por ciento; en 2010, era el
15,1 por ciento; y en 2019, era el 10,5 por ciento." [En 2021 era del 11,6% (Fuente https://www.census.gov/newsroom/stories/poverty-awareness-month.html) Eso supone unos 39
millones de personas. Eso es igual a la
población de California -adición de Malloy].
"... Los primeros cinco años [de LBJ] en el cargo, un nivel
de actividad impresionante. ¿Y el resultado? Diez años después de la puesta en
marcha del primero de estos programas en 1964, la proporción de estadounidenses
que vivían en la pobreza era la mitad que en 1960."
"... los teléfonos móviles se han hecho más asequibles en
las últimas décadas, y ahora la mayoría de los estadounidenses tienen uno,
incluidos muchos pobres. Esto ha llevado ... a altos cargos de la Brookings
Institution, a afirmar que "el acceso a ciertos bienes de consumo",
como televisores, hornos microondas y teléfonos móviles, demuestra que
"los pobres no son tan pobres después de todo".
No, no es así. No se puede comer un teléfono móvil. Un teléfono móvil no te garantiza una vivienda
estable, una atención médica y dental asequible o un cuidado infantil adecuado.
De hecho, a medida que cosas como los teléfonos móviles se han abaratado, el
coste de las necesidades vitales más necesarias, como la atención sanitaria y
el alquiler, ha aumentado. De 2000 a 2022, en una ciudad estadounidense media,
el coste del combustible y los servicios públicos aumentó un 115%. Los pobres
estadounidenses, que viven en el centro del capitalismo mundial, tienen acceso
a bienes baratos producidos en masa, como todos los estadounidenses. Pero eso
no significa que puedan acceder a lo que más importa. Como dijo Michael
Harrington hace 60 años: "En Estados Unidos es mucho más fácil estar
decentemente vestido que estar decentemente alojado, alimentado o aseado".
Reagan amplió el poder de las
empresas, recortó profundamente los impuestos a los ricos y redujo el gasto en
algunas iniciativas contra la pobreza, especialmente en vivienda. Pero fue
incapaz de hacer recortes a gran escala y a largo plazo en muchos de los
programas que conforman el Estado del bienestar estadounidense. ... No hay pruebas de que Estados Unidos se
haya vuelto más tacaño con el paso del tiempo. Todo lo contrario. Esto hace aún más
desconcertante el estancado progreso del país en materia de pobreza. Década
tras década, la tasa de pobreza se ha mantenido estable a pesar del aumento de
las ayudas federales.
Si hemos duplicado con creces el gasto público en pobreza y
hemos conseguido tan poco, una de las razones es que el Estado del bienestar
estadounidense es un cubo agujereado. Con la reforma de 1996 de la Asistencia
Temporal para Familias Necesitadas (TANF, por sus siglas en inglés), el
presidente Clinton transformó el programa en una subvención en bloque que da a
los estados un margen considerable para decidir cómo distribuir el dinero. Como
resultado, los estados han ideado formas bastante creativas de gastar el dinero
del TANF. Arizona ha utilizado el dinero de la ayuda social para pagar la
educación sexual basada únicamente en la abstinencia. Pensilvania desvió fondos
del TANF a centros antiaborto para mujeres embarazadas en crisis. Maine utilizó
el dinero para financiar un campamento de verano cristiano. En todo el país, por
cada dólar presupuestado para el TANF en 2020,
las familias pobres recibieron directamente sólo
22 céntimos.
"Hay, al parecer, fuerzas estructurales más profundas en
juego, que tienen que ver con la forma en que se aprovechan rutinariamente de
los pobres estadounidenses. La razón principal de nuestro estancado progreso en
la reducción de la pobreza tiene que ver con el hecho de que no nos hemos
enfrentado a la implacable explotación de los pobres en los mercados laboral,
inmobiliario y financiero."
"...larga historia de explotación de los barrios marginales
en Estados Unidos. El dinero hizo los barrios marginales porque los barrios
marginales hicieron dinero. El alquiler se ha más que
duplicado en las últimas dos décadas, aumentando mucho más rápido que los
ingresos de los inquilinos. El alquiler medio
pasó de 483 dólares en 2000 a 1.216 dólares en 2021".
"Según el F.D.I.C., uno de cada 19 hogares estadounidenses
no tenía cuenta bancaria en 2019, lo que supone más de siete millones de
familias. En comparación con las familias blancas, las familias negras e
hispanas tenían casi cinco veces más probabilidades de carecer de una cuenta
bancaria. Donde hay exclusión, hay explotación. Los estadounidenses sin cuenta
bancaria han creado un mercado, y miles de establecimientos de cambio de
cheques sirven ahora a ese mercado. Los establecimientos de cambio de cheques
suelen cobrar entre el 1% y el 10% del total, según el tipo de cheque".
"[Una novela] describe el problema de los suicidios en las
reservas de nativos americanos dice: "Los niños saltan por
las ventanas de edificios en llamas, caen al vacío y mueren. Y creemos que el
problema es que están saltando". El debate sobre la
pobreza ha sufrido un tipo similar de miopía. Durante el último medio siglo,
hemos abordado la cuestión de la pobreza señalando a los propios pobres
-planteando preguntas sobre su ética laboral, digamos, o sus prestaciones
sociales- cuando deberíamos habernos centrado en el fuego. La pregunta que debería servir como encantamiento en bucle, la que
deberíamos hacernos cada vez que pasamos en coche por delante de un campamento
de tiendas de campaña, esos tugurios estadounidenses alquitranados que huelen a
asfalto y cadáveres, o cada vez que vemos a alguien dormido en el autobús,
desplomado en ropa de trabajo, es simplemente: ¿A quién beneficia? No: ¿Por qué no encuentras un trabajo mejor? O: ¿Por qué no te
mudas? O: ¿Por qué no dejas de pedir préstamos? Sino: ¿Quién se está alimentando de esto?"
Jesús le dijo a Judas: "A los pobres los tendréis siempre
con vosotros" (Juan 12:4-5). La
gente como Judas mantiene a la gente en la pobreza. Jesús quiere que liberemos a todo el mundo de
todas las esclavitudes y diminishe
La Paz,
P. Ricardo Malloy, S.J.
Sigamos Seguro. Sigamos Sano. Sigamos Sonriendo