Sunday, May 27, 2012

Glenn Loury on James Q. Wilson's Questionable Legacy

Good Questions for our Wilson influenced Criminal Justice system.

********************************************************

http://www.bostonreview.net/BR37.3/glenn_loury_james_q_wilson_culture_poverty_crime_race.php

Much to Answer For

James Q. Wilson’s Legacy
Zen Sutherland
The esteemed political scientist and criminologist James Q. Wilson died in March. He wrote many important works, including a leading textbook on American government currently in its twelfth edition. He was awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom in 2003.
His most significant legacy, however, lies in the impact of his scholarship and journalism on the contemporary structures of social control in the United States. His 1975 book Thinking About Crime provides academic justification for a massive increase in imprisonment in the United States that began in the late 1970s and has yet fully to run its course. (The United States incarcerates at five times the rate of Britain, the leading jailer in Europe.) It is therefore entirely fitting—indeed, imperative—that there be extensive, critical public discussion about the intellectual impact of this towering figure of the study of American government.
While I came to disagree sharply with him on criminal justice policy, I must acknowledge that I liked Jim Wilson, the man. He was urbane, witty, and generous with his time. He was unfailingly open to hearing both sides of any argument. I knew him to be loyal to a fault, even-tempered, and often a wise observer of American politics. I admired his modesty and his prodigious work ethic. Indeed, my appreciation of “Gentleman Jim” dates back nearly three decades, to 1983, when he came to my humble Afro-American Studies office at Harvard, practically hat in hand, with a draft chapter on “race and crime” for an as-yet-unpublished book, Crime and Human Nature. He was writing it with Richard Herrnstein, who would go on to write The Bell Curve (1994) with Charles Murray. Wilson asked for my unsparing critique, which I provided. It impressed me that, when the book appeared two years later, he and Herrnstein had taken my criticisms seriously.
I went on to work closely with Wilson on a number of projects. In 1987 we co-edited a volume on families, schools, and delinquency prevention. We served together for a decade on the editorial board of the influential neoconservative magazine The Public Interest. And in the early 1990s we were colleagues on the Council of Academic Advisors at the American Enterprise Institute.
That last association ended for me in 1995, when I publicly resigned my position after AEI fellows wrote two incendiary and what seemed to me borderline racist books—The Bell Curve and The End of Racism (1995), by Dinesh D’Souza. In those years, and partly in response to those two books, I began my long march out of the right wing of American intellectual life. And, in so doing, I slowly came to the view—which I continue to hold—that some of Wilson’s labors have done enormous damage to the quality of American democracy. His rationalizing and legitimating of over-reliance on incarceration in U.S. social policy have been particularly destructive. It frustrates me that even as mounting evidence over the past decade showed that crime control had become too punitive, Wilson stubbornly reiterated the views that he had developed four decades ago.
As a public policy intellectual, Wilson was the product of a particular moment in American history. One has to think of him in connection with such writers as his mentor in the Harvard government department, Edward Banfield; his friend and colleague at The Public Interest, Nathan Glazer; and his compatriot and like-minded social critic, Daniel Patrick Moynihan. That generation saw the postwar liberal belief in the possibility of a progressive resolution to the “urban problem” crash upon the rocky shoals of the riot-torn, welfare-fed, criminal, and black 1960s metropolis. While the left did not distinguish itself in those years, neither did Wilson’s cohort. Considered from today’s perspective, much of what the nascent neoconservative thinkers had to say was pretty appalling. Banfield’s classic lament of the failures of 1960s urban policy, The Unheavenly City, looks an awful lot like reactionary drivel. (His argument that persistent poverty is due to the bad values and character of the poor—first set out in his book about Italy, The Moral Basis of a Backward Society—might have made sense for Sicily, but did not travel well to the South Bronx.) And in retrospect Moynihan—whose work Wilson often extolled—hardly comes off looking like a great thinker. Calling a spade a spade turns out not to be a social policy.
In my long march out of the right wing, I came to believe that Wilson’s labors did enormous damage to American democracy.
Call me unforgiving, but I can still remember sitting at Jim and Roberta Wilson’s dinner table in Malibu, California in January 1993 listening to Murray explain, much to my consternation and with Jim’s silent acquiescence, that social inequality is inevitable because “dull” parents are simply less effective at child-rearing than “bright” ones. (I rejected then, and still do, Murray and Herrnstein’s claim that profound social disparities are due mainly to variation in innate individual traits that cannot be remedied via social policy.) Neither can Glenn Loury in 2012 ignore what he failed to see in 1983: that Wilson and Herrnstein’s Crime and Human Nature—a book that sets out to lay bare the underlying bio-genetic, somatic, and psychological determinants of individuals’ criminal behavior—is an enterprise of dubious scientific value. The behavioral theories of social control that Wilson spawned—see, for instance, his 1983 Atlantic Monthly piece, “Raising Kids” (not unlike training pets, as it happens)—and the pop–social psychology salesmanship of his and George Kelling’s so-called “theory” about broken windows is a long way from rocket science, or even good social science. This work looks more like narrative in the service of rationalizing and justifying hierarchy, subordination, coercion, and control. In short, it smacks of highbrow, reactionary journalism.
But, unlike most tabloid scribblers, Wilson’s writings had a massive effect. The broken windows argument—by cracking down on minor offenses, the police can prevent the perception of disorder that leads to more serious crimes—has influenced urban law enforcement strategists throughout the nation. Even so, as scholarly critics across the ideological spectrum have noted, there is little evidence beyond the anecdotal to show that such “quality of life” policing actually leads to lower crime rates. When I consider the impact of his ideas, I can’t help but think about the millions of folks being hassled even as we speak by coercive state agents who are acting on some Wilsonian theory recommending stop-and-frisk policing.
Neither can I overlook the reinforcement of subliminal racial stigmata associated with the institutions of confinement, surveillance, and patrol that Americans have embraced over the past two generations under the watchful and approving gaze of Professor Wilson.
I don’t think Jim Wilson had a racist bone in his body. Neither do I doubt his sincerity when he expressed regret, as he often did, that blacks are overrepresented among those being punished for having committed crimes. But intent is one thing; results are another. A politics of vengeance has abetted the unprecedented rise in U.S. incarceration rates since 1980. I am made keenly aware of the deleterious impact these policies have had on residents of urban black communities, law-abiders and law-breakers alike. This was not Wilson’s intent, but plainly it was one consequence of ideas that he championed.
Was Jim Wilson fair-minded and decent? Yes. Did he run a good meeting? Was he an effective academic entrepreneur? Yes to both. Was he often a penetrating observer of and always a prolific writer on American politics? To be sure. Was he right about the direction that incarceration needed to go in 1970? Perhaps. Did liberals underestimate the fierce political backlash from the disgruntled ethnic working classes circa 1975, as Wilson strongly argued? Yes, they did. Wilson was not wrong about everything.
But is his 1997 book The Moral Sense—which cites human nature to make a case against moral relativism, and which Wilson thought his most important publication—a work for the ages? I doubt it seriously. Is Thinking About Crime up there in the pantheon of American social criticism along with Silent SpringThe Other AmericaThe Feminine Mystique, or The Fire Next Time? Not hardly.
James Q. Wilson was not the Thomas Hobbes of our time—though it is a good guess that he fancied himself grappling with a Leviathan. A cloistered moral sanctimony (“Tobacco shortens one’s life; cocaine debases it”) coupled with an enthusiasm for police work (“prison in America . . . helps explain why this country has a lower rate of burglary than Australia, Austria, Canada, England, Germany, and the Netherlands”): that’s another way to think about the legacy of James Q. Wilson. Unkind to be sure, but not inaccurate.
With all due respect to the influence of his writings on bureaucracy, policing, and social policy, I’m just not buying the hagiographies that appeared in the likes of the Wall Street Journal, Los Angeles Times, and Boston Globe

33 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Wilson's ideas saved many many lives especially in NYC

Fri Jun 01, 08:51:00 PM 2012  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Born and raised in NYC. The police are much better today. As a sociologist I'm surprised you posted this? What's your take on broken windows?

Sun Jun 03, 02:44:00 PM 2012  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Evеrything іѕ verу open with a clеаr deѕcriptiοn оf thе chаllenges.
It ωas ԁefinitelу informаtіve.
Yοuг wеbsite is extrеmеly helρful.

Thanks for sharіng!

my site - personal loans

Thu Feb 28, 12:07:00 PM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

4 2011 he vaulted past Britney Spears in the Most Twitter Followers category.

So that certain amount of money that you pay for your followers is justified as you can be sure
that your money will come back to you thanks to those followers.
All you have to do is start taking action by building your list of targeted followers.


Here is my homepage :: Buy cheap Twitter Followers

Tue Mar 19, 08:48:00 PM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Its like уоu read my mind! Yоu appear to know sο much аbout this, liκe you wrоte thе book in it οr somеthing.
Ι think that yοu could do ωіth some piсs to driѵe the mesѕage home a littlе bіt,
but іnsteаd of thаt, this is wondеrful blog.
A great reаd. I will cеrtainly be bacκ.

mу blog :: payday

Sat Mar 23, 09:16:00 PM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Ηi, i think thаt і saw you vіsіted
my sitе so i came to “гeturn the favor”.
I am attemptіng to fіnd things to
enhance mу websitе!I suppose its ok to use some of your іԁеas!
!

my sitе :: payday loans

Thu Mar 28, 12:29:00 AM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I have been surfing οnline gгeateг than three houгs as of
lаtе, yet Ι never ԁiѕcονeгеd any interesting articlе liκе
yours. It's lovely worth enough for me. In my opinion, if all site owners and bloggers made just right content material as you did, the internet will likely be a lot more useful than ever before.

My web page cash loans

Thu Apr 04, 10:26:00 PM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

It is high time that businesses not only open their windows and doors but
make their walls transparent as well

my web page; online reputation management

Fri Apr 05, 09:09:00 PM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This process also produces a more concentrated form of
fish oil supplement with high potencies of EPA and DHA

Check out my web blog: omega3

Fri Apr 05, 11:53:00 PM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

These dresses represented for dignity of their nation

My website ... simple informal wedding dresses

Sat Apr 06, 10:55:00 AM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I'm very pleased to uncover this web site. I wanted to thank you for your time just for this fantastic read!! I definitely really liked every bit of it and I have you book-marked to check out new things on your blog.

Here is my page web hosting coupons

Sat Apr 06, 02:08:00 PM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Always ensure you choose a method that is
proven to remove skin tags without causing adverse effects and scarring.
Another available treatment option that can be done at home without a prescription is a topical ointment.
Those with sensitive skin should not use it as it can irritate.


Have a look at my homepage :: Skin tags removal

Sat Apr 06, 10:48:00 PM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Third party coupon websites will provide you coupons

Visit my web-site; refer to this article for more information

Mon Apr 08, 10:23:00 PM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

While the business cycle involves the two main phases of
expansion and contraction, it can be further divided into
six distinct stages

Check out my site: Check Out http://sixflagsticketscouons.com/six-flags-discovery-kingdom/

Thu Apr 11, 02:46:00 AM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

However, before making the payments, you can ask the service provider about the time frame,
in which they will be able to deliver the views. When you want to give the appearance that you have a lot of views
for your video, buy Youtube views. When they are done with their events; the one
thing that strikes their mind is You - Tube because they want others to be a part
of the event and relish the memories.

Feel free to visit my blog post - youtube video views

Fri Apr 12, 09:02:00 PM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

After looking into а number of thе агticleѕ on
your web page, I truly аppreсiate your ωay of blogging.
I added it to my boоkmark website lіst аnd will be checking back soοn.

Please visіt my website tοο and let me knoω
your ορinіon.

my web-site; payday loans

Sun Apr 14, 11:20:00 AM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Greаt blog here! Also уour wеbѕite loads uр fast!
What ωeb host aгe yοu using? Сan I get your аffiliatе linκ to your host?

І wish my web site lοaded up aѕ quickly аs yours lоl

Review mу weblog ... payday loans

Sun May 26, 04:42:00 AM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

ecigs, smokeless cigarettes, smokeless cigarettes, e cigarettes, electronic cigarette, best electronic cigarettes

Sat Nov 29, 04:20:00 PM 2014  
Blogger Unknown said...

louboutin femme pas cher
lululemon
christian louboutin shoes
jordan 11
concord 11
abercrombie and fitch
michael kors watches
michael kors outlet
true religion outlet
kobe 8
michael kors
timberland outlet
ralph lauren bedding
louis vuitton
true religion sale
michael kors handbags
louis vuitton outlet
lululemon headbands
abercrombie
jordan 13 retro
coach outlet online
michael kors
jordans 9
louis vuitton
chi hair strighteners
oakley sunglasses outlet
prada bags
jordan retro 3
christian louboutin sale
michael kors outlet
nike air max
louis vuitton outlet
jordan retro 8
gucci outlet online
red bottom shoes
tory burch outlet online
20150630xiong

Tue Jun 30, 02:48:00 AM 2015  
Blogger chenlina said...

chenlina20151202
oakley sunglasses
cheap uggs
louis vuitton outlet
replica watches
coach outlet
christian louboutin outlet
jordans for sale
ugg outlet
canada goose outlet
hollister co,hollister jeans,hollister.com,hollister ca
uggs on sale
nike air max
oakley sunglasses
michael kors handbags
canada goose outlet online
louis vuitton
cheap ugg boots
oakley sunglasses
swarovski outlet
louis vuitton
michael kors outlet
kids uggs on sale
michael kors handbags
ugg boots
gucci shoes
cheap uggs for sale
michael kors outlet online
ugg boots
oakley sunglasses cheap
christian louboutin shoes
the north face outlet
michael kors outlet
air max 95
longchamp outlet
coach factory outlet
michael kors outlet
louis vuitton handbags
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet
cheap air jordans
as

Wed Dec 02, 02:08:00 AM 2015  
Blogger chenlina said...

chenlina20151209
ugg boots
coach outlet
abercrombie kids
toms shoes
louis vuitton outlet online
michael kors outlet
gucci shoes
hollister co
coach factory outlet
michael kors outlet online
michael kors outlet online
canada goose jackets
uggs for men
coach factory outlet
canada goose outlet
air force 1
fake oakley sunglasses
timberland outlet
michael kors outlet
ugg outlet
louis vuitton handbags
michael kors outlet
ed hardy clothing
louis vuitton handbags
louis vuitton
prada handbags
cheap uggs
ray ban sunglasses
michaek kors outlet
oakley sunglasses
hollister uk
ralph lauren outlet
ray ban sunglasses
nike air max
cheap ugg boots
true religion outlet
michael kors outlet online
polo ralph lauren outlet
uggs outlet
ray ban sunglasses outlet
as

Wed Dec 09, 12:27:00 AM 2015  
Blogger ninest123 said...

ninest123 16.01
true religion jeans, air max pas cher, longchamp, timberland, nike air max, converse pas cher, nike blazer, michael kors uk, vans pas cher, north face, sac guess, sac burberry, nike air force, ray ban sunglasses, polo ralph lauren, hollister, north face, true religion outlet, coach outlet store online, michael kors outlet, louboutin, lululemon outlet online, ralph lauren, abercrombie and fitch, true religion outlet, michael kors, true religion jeans, nike huaraches, air max, nike free, longchamp, oakley pas cher, michael kors pas cher, hollister, new balance pas cher, sac hermes, air jordan, nike roshe run pas cher, mulberry, hogan outlet, ray ban pas cher, replica handbags, nike tn, nike roshe, vanessa bruno, nike free pas cher, nike trainers, air max, sac longchamp pas cher, coach purses, polo lacoste

Thu Jan 28, 09:50:00 PM 2016  
Blogger ninest123 said...

tory burch outlet, jordan shoes, oakley sunglasses, michael kors outlet, oakley sunglasses, michael kors outlet, chanel handbags, longchamp outlet, uggs outlet, ugg boots clearance, burberry outlet, tiffany and co, nike shoes, michael kors outlet online sale, louis vuitton, cheap uggs, prada outlet, oakley sunglasses, polo ralph lauren outlet, louis vuitton handbags, michael kors outlet, replica watches, ray ban sunglasses, nike free, ugg outlet, louboutin outlet, ray ban sunglasses, louis vuitton outlet, oakley sunglasses cheap, cheap oakley sunglasses, air max, tiffany and co, louis vuitton outlet, ray ban sunglasses, louboutin shoes, longchamp handbags, burberry outlet, longchamp handbags, prada handbags, louis vuitton outlet stores, air max, uggs, michael kors outlet, polo ralph lauren, michael kors outlet, louboutin, rolex watches, gucci outlet, christian louboutin

Thu Jan 28, 09:53:00 PM 2016  
Blogger ninest123 said...

soccer shoes, bottega veneta, instyler, iphone 6s plus cases, converse, nfl jerseys, soccer jerseys, iphone 6s cases, mcm handbags, p90x, jimmy choo outlet, baseball bats, ghd, north face jackets, iphone 6 plus cases, iphone 6 cases, ipad cases, hollister clothing store, air max, babyliss pro, chi flat iron, iphone cases, beats by dre, valentino shoes, timberland boots, mac cosmetics, vans shoes, celine handbags, insanity workout, asics running shoes, ferragamo shoes, wedding dresses, north face outlet, abercrombie and fitch, oakley, ralph lauren, air max, mont blanc, lululemon outlet, reebok outlet, abercrombie, s6 case, gucci, herve leger, ray ban, birkin bag, new balance shoes, iphone 5s cases, vans, nike roshe run, louboutin, giuseppe zanotti

Thu Jan 28, 09:57:00 PM 2016  
Blogger ninest123 said...

hollister, ugg, canada goose, moncler, pandora jewelry, rolex watches, montre homme, moncler, sac lancel, thomas sabo, moncler, swarovski crystal, sac louis vuitton, ugg, louis vuitton, links of london, barbour, moncler, juicy couture outlet, moncler outlet, canada goose, ugg pas cher, converse shoes, pandora jewelry, louis vuitton, doke gabbana, swarovski, coach outlet store online, pandora charms, canada goose, moncler, canada goose, juicy couture, pandora charms, supra shoes, moncler, canada goose uk, canada goose, ugg, marc jacobs, moncler, ugg boots, canada goose outlet, sac louis vuitton, canada goose jackets, barbour, wedding dresses, karen millen, toms shoes, louis vuitton uk
ninest123 16.01

Thu Jan 28, 10:00:00 PM 2016  
Blogger Hua Cai said...

coach outlet online
air max 2015
louis vuitton
cheap soccer jerseys
michael kors outlet online
tory burch outlet
michael kors outlet uk
ferragamo outlet
herve leger outlet
true religion outlet
20160930caihuali

Thu Sep 29, 10:43:00 PM 2016  
Blogger Unknown said...

beats by dr dre
true religion sale
ralph lauren polo
cartier watches
calvin klein underwear
ferragamo shoes
nike air max 2015
rolex watches
coach outlet store online
supra shoes
chanyuan11.19

Fri Nov 18, 01:59:00 PM 2016  
Blogger Abhijit said...

For getting an increased publicity for your products or personality, Folks expend bucks to Buy Facebook Comments to very easily get direct exposure instantly. buy facebook status comments

Tue Feb 07, 08:16:00 AM 2017  
Blogger Abhijit said...

Are you eager to get global popularity swiftly? You require to Buy Facebook Comments to become well known to our world. facebook comments

Thu Feb 09, 06:30:00 AM 2017  
Blogger vishal bhagat said...

Are you currently looking for good revelation to the skills and professional abilities on LinkedIn? The very best resolution is thru Buying LinkedIn Connections, Followers and Endorsements. visit here to buy connections on linkedin

Mon Feb 13, 08:06:00 AM 2017  
Blogger vishal bhagat said...

Buying LinkedIn Followers, Connections and Endorsements, is truly the most recent option for improving your professional identification. To grasp just a few strategies concerning this, stay going through this web site. buying linkedin followers

Tue Feb 14, 09:08:00 AM 2017  
Blogger vishal bhagat said...

To buy legitimate and true LinkedIn Followers, Connections and Endorsements, you may contact us. This may help you to strengthen your professional identification on internet. buy linkedin connection

Sat Feb 18, 07:36:00 AM 2017  
Blogger Unknown said...

jianbin0225
coach outlet store
louis vuitton
omega watches
ray ban sunglasses
oakley sunglasses
coach outlet online coach factory outlet
michael kors
cheap nfl jersey
kobe bryant shoes
adidas wings

Sat Feb 25, 01:37:00 AM 2017  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home