Monday, June 25, 2012

Justice has a lot to do with it: Timothy Luke Johnson's Review of Margaret Farley's' Just Love


Timothy Luke Johnson

Sr. Margaret Farley, RSM and her book Just Love

Commonweal provides Timothy Luke Johnson's 2007 Review of Margaret Farley's' Just Love


January 26, 2007
Books

What's Justice Got to Do with It?

Just Love  A Framework for Christian Sexual Ethics  Margaret Farley Continuum, $29.95, 336 pp.
Luke Timothy Johnson

At a time of high-volume recrimination, when all that seem to count are loud opinions on specific hot-button topics, few things require more boldness than quietly to propose a “framework for Christian sexual ethics” that asks readers to ponder basic principles rather than rush to precipitous conclusions. And few people are better qualified to offer such an unexpected proposal than Margaret Farley, the Gilbert L. Stark Professor of Christian Ethics at Yale Divinity School since 1971.
As a feminist, a Roman Catholic, and a religious (Sister of Mercy) teaching ethics in a liberal university during an era of ideological and ecclesiastical turmoil over sexuality, Farley could scarcely have hoped to avoid public controversy. And indeed, at times she has become a point of polarization, honored by fellow theologians and excoriated by bloggers for such positions as her stated belief that homosexuality “can be a way of embodying responsible human love and sustaining Christian friendship.” To the many students who worked with her over the past thirty-five years, however, and to those who have read her books and articles, Farley is best known for her largeness of spirit and for the demanding intelligence she brings to her teaching and writing.
Her new book exudes those qualities. In Just Love, Farley seeks not so much to persuade as to invite readers to a way of thinking that can move the conversation about sexual morality forward. Her project is constructive and, like any foundation-laying, requires patience. I must confess that in my own reading, I grew a little impatient with the space given to spadework, and felt the urge to page ahead. Yet serious readers will do well to pay attention from start to finish. Farley’s manner is academic but not obscure, and once readers grow comfortable with it, they will reap the benefits of wisdom gleaned from decades of teaching and scholarship.
In her introduction, Farley ties the need for a new framework for sexual ethics to the explosive growth in knowledge in our time. The natural sciences have tremendously complicated our notions of gender and sexuality, even as history and the social sciences have revealed the partial character of our prior normative discourse concerning what is “natural” and “proper.” Failing to work at a framework capacious and sturdy enough to encompass such new knowledge is intellectually irresponsible, Farley suggests; and bearing authentic Christian witness requires intellectual responsibility.
The next three sections of Just Love challenge Christian ethics to come to grips with a new cognitive situation. “The Questions and Their Past” takes up the complexities of sex, morality, and history in theories of interpretation from Foucault to evolutionary psychology, and charts the evolution of sexual ethics in the West, sketching normative positions from Greece and Rome to the Enlightenment and adding recent medical perspectives. Farley simplifies these large topics in an appropriate and illuminating fashion. In “Difficult Crossings: Diverse Traditions,” she briefly surveys the impact of cross-cultural realities, outlining the theoretical issues involved in learning from other cultures, and offering data from the South Seas, traditional African culture, Hinduism, and Islam. Finally, she gives explicit attention to “Sexuality and Its Meanings,” beginning with how the body matters, moving to whether gender matters, and concluding with sexuality and its meanings.
Up to this point all the attention in Just Love has been on the “is,” with no element of “ought,” and some readers may grow restless with the apparent lack of a normative argument. Farley tests us further by turning in chapter 5 to still another apparently theoretical discussion. First, she elaborates on her decision to locate Christian sexual ethics within the framework of justice, instead of a number of available alternatives. Second, she discusses the sources for Christian sexual ethics, adopting a form of the Wesleyan Quadrilateral. (Her understandings of Scripture and tradition are those of a moderate liberal, but her conception of reason and experience is more expansive than one might expect: reason, for example, clearly includes “secular disciplines of knowledge,” and experience seems to embrace a wide range of “contemporary experience.”) Finally, she defends “just love,” rather than simply “love,” as the proper approach to sexual ethics. Love may sound nobler, but it is also more elusive; justice may seem minimalist, but without it love is empty.
In chapter 6, “Framework for a Sexual Ethic: Just Love,” Farley turns to her understanding of justice, focusing on “the concrete reality of persons” and the “obligating features of personhood.” She lists seven norms that must be met in order for decisions about sexual acts and dispositions to be just: no unjust harm; free consent; mutuality; equality; commitment; fruitfulness; and social justice. This rich chapter concludes with Farley’s thoughts on how “just love” works as a Christian ethic, as well as a human and social one. Finally, all these discussions come to a focus in the closing chapter, “Patterns of Relationship: Contexts for Just Love.” The three patterns are “marriage and family,” “same-sex relationships,” and “divorce and remarriage.” For each of these complex questions, Farley summons resources arrayed in the opening chapters and moves toward normative judgments.
To criticize Farley’s “opinions” on any of these difficult questions would be to betray the entire spirit of her project, which emphasizes not particular conclusions, but the process of reasoning responsibly and well toward a conclusion. Nor would it be to the point to complain that Just Love does not cover everything that comes under the heading of sexual ethics, or even that it fails to cover adequately its own examples; all Farley’s topics were deployed to illustrate thinking justly within the framework she has established.
Instead, I direct my criticisms to the framework itself. Some elements of the ethical structure built up in Just Love are less clearly developed than they might be, especially in light of the “Christian” dimension of the book’s subtitle. Farley pays little attention to the ecclesial character of sexual ethics. How does the church’s standard of holiness with respect to the body come into play? How might the church as a community play a role in discerning appropriate codes of personal behavior? And how can this discerning activity (which properly puts emphasis on human experience) negotiate the often difficult declarations of the magisterium? The last is a special issue for Catholics, to be sure, but it is scarcely foreign to other ecclesial bodies struggling with sexual ethics.
Farley’s effort to describe a person-based sexual ethics that moves easily to a sexual ethics based in justice is certainly consonant with Christian identity; but is it distinctive to Christian identity, or does it arise from what is distinctive in Christian commitment? The answer may be that it need not be distinctively Christian in order to be fully Christian, but I would like to see the point argued more fully. Finally, while I appreciate that Scripture is but one of the resources available for normative moral discourse, I would have appreciated a more robust engagement with both the problems and possibilities offered by biblical witness; Farley’s method as a scholar ends up giving more space to the Samoans than to Scripture.
These questions, I want to make clear, arise from a deeply sympathetic reading of Farley’s argument. I consider Just Love an important resource and spur for further collaboration among Christians and others on the knotty issues of sexual ethics. Throughout her book, Farley evinces the sort of intellectual modesty that comes from great learning and an open mind. She recognizes how little we actually know about many of the issues on which we confidently make normative judgments, and I appreciate her insistence on our need to know “what is the case” before we proclaim “what must be so.” Such openness to other cultures (and to science) is not a function of political correctness but of theological appropriateness. Farley insists that the mystery of human embodiedness demands not only respect at the moral level, but also modesty at the cognitive one.
An example of how respect and modesty can make a difference for normative discourse within Christianity is the splendid discussion in Just Love of intersex persons, those born with both male and female sexual organs. Farley reveals how impoverished our Western world’s two-gender-only understanding of humans is when compared with the recognized place of “third gendered” persons in some cultures. She discusses how the obsession with “fixing” intersex children into an acceptable gender, through surgery and socialization, leads to numerous problems among the “fixed.” The lesson here is that we should not be impatient with what we do not understand. Farley notes that even if only a tiny fraction of the world’s population is born in this condition, it is still a massive number of bodies from which God wants us to learn something concerning what is or is not “according to nature.” Here Farley’s argument that the moral issue is not love but justice makes a great deal of sense.
Just Love does not provide all the answers concerning sexual ethics. But it does lay out a serious and solid framework for thinking about them. It is perhaps too much to hope that this fine effort can escape the sort of polarized responses that the temper of the times seems to elicit.

11 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Romans 1:25-27
They exchanged the truth of God for a lie and revered and worshiped the creature rather than the creator, who is blessed forever. Amen. Therefore, God handed them over to degrading passions. Their females exchanged natural relations for unnatural, and the males likewise gave up natural relations with females and burned with lust for one another. Males did shameful things with males and thus received in their own persons the due penalty for their perversity.

Mon Sep 03, 09:02:00 PM 2012  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

gathered in the hotel while [url=http://www.ddtshanghaiescort.com]beijing massage[/url] eating breakfast muttering commandedthe Avenue down than changes in the market

Tue Feb 05, 08:23:00 PM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hello. And Bye.
http://www.artofdrkara.com/gucci.html
http://admireyemen.com/test.htm
http://www.artofdrkara.com/lv.html
http://www.garychicagoairport.com/Michael-Kors-bags.asp
http://prestigeboardingkennel.com/feed.html

Mon Apr 29, 12:03:00 AM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hello. And Bye.
http://pon.tw/old/viewthread.php?tid=148344&extra=
http://www.tynkahra.org/blog/2011/11/post-437.html#comments
http://rickrodgers.com/rick_rodgers/rr/2012/01/sunday-night-spaghetti-and-meatballs.html#comments
http://groups.google.com/group/b2evolution-pt/browse_thread/thread/2709463ddc637848/
http://www.altsoftware.com/sample#comment-168094

Mon Apr 29, 12:06:00 AM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Dr.

Finally, when poor women have children they can qualify for supportive services such as housing and other benefits than a man would not have access to..

Also, be sure and take the poll and share your opinion on an Alexander McQueen inspired dress that is entirely made of candy!.

Returning to Denver in 2007 to take a break from fashion, she began working as an event planner.

Ce que je vais te dire ne va peut-etre pas te rassurer mais nous n'avons pas fait les soldes, ni moi, ni mes deux enfants.

Tue May 07, 09:13:00 AM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Window seats and ottomans with storage under the cushions are a good choice as are coffee tables, end tables and night stands with shelving or drawers.

Go to bed, you lunatic.".

This bag can be worn as a messenger or just flung on your arm when you are on the go.

Jennifer Lopez a un sens du style tr猫s aguis茅 et s'assume compl猫tement ce qui fait qu'elle figure rarement sur nos listes des pires tenues de stars.

Vous aurez structur茅 de fa?on 脿 obtenir d茅tendre partie burberry maillot de bain semblable aux plages et bords de mer aussi.

Tue May 07, 04:39:00 PM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Since the early 1990s until now, this kind of shoes are widely used by many top-class people..

Depending on the design and use of the age, the insignia may change.

La manera es una parte importante del mundo.

Bolivia.

MaterialThough vous trouverez diff茅rents composants faciles 脿 obtenir dans les zones, s茅lectionnez mieux un seul.

Wed May 08, 03:16:00 AM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The strap spreads the weight of the bag across the wearer back and shoulders and has a sleek style that is suitable for both men and women.

Unfortunately, licorice supplements may induce severe or potentially life-threatening side effects.

With its red-brick office blocks, sprawling Convention Center and waterfront piers, Fort Point Channel in Boston would seem an odd place for an arty fashion boutique like the Achilles Project.

She also has taken an active role with the Diabetes Research Institute (DRI) at the University of Miami, a recognized leader in cure-focused research..

Timberland Boots For Men aspirations of people in the natural joy in the pursuit of physical and mental, rather than athletic performance can be Timberland Classic Boots measured.

Wed May 08, 03:44:00 AM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hello there! I could have sworn I've visited this website before but after browsing through some of the posts I realized it's
new to me. Regardless, I'm certainly pleased I came across it and I'll be bookmarking it and checking back regularly!


My web blog cheap nike air max

Sat May 11, 05:00:00 PM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

It's a stupendous bright afternoon on the sting of the Androscoggin water, fantastic hour northwest concerning Portld. [url=http://raybanblueraybancoupon.zohosites.com]ray ban blue[/url] g,together with|among them|something like|instance|comparable to|just like for example|for instance,akin to|equivalent to|illustration|corresponding to|say like,resembling|for instance such as|example|reminiscent of|this includes|related to|i.
s,america|american|me|everyone|our company|united states of america|states|mankind|our business|our family|all of|most of us|country|associated with us|users|nation|folks|our site|our team|unites states|associated with|the company|u. [url=http://raybanwomenraybanway.zohosites.com]ray ban women[/url] e,for|eg|with regard to|specifically|much like|such like|include things like|such as|by way of example|regarding} friends or family in a secure, potentially your entire a holiday seek refuge which you can spare put together area to as a irritate off to, what do you do? whole lot info has been developed within the liable, rather than better often to remain seated store at the home in order to avoid a new bulk exodus about out of an american city.once you have organized extremely well it is usually better to wait your location unless all over on foot the way within something dangerous or possibly a debilitating.
e,for|eg|with regard to|specifically|much like|such like|include things like|such as|by way of example|regarding} made of wool cotton. [url=http://raybanraybansunglasses.zohosites.com]ray ban wayfarer[/url] org|clist|craiglist|craigs list} {and|as well as|and also|along with|in addition to|plus|together with|and even|not to mention|and additionally|and then|coupled with|and therefore|also|and thus|combined with|or|and so|and in addition|and furthermore|and consequently|then|and as well,as well as the|and moreover|and as a result|and as a consequence|to|but|so|and simply|additionally|but also|and as well as|in addition|furthermore|in addition to the|and as well|moreover|as well|and after that|as well as,while|as|with|on top of that|in addition,yet|and / or|since} {ebay|auction web sites|craigs list|amazon|craigslist and ebay|the ebay affiliate network|ebay.
a new IIHS guidelines eight forms, yet a mere sorts of five enjoyed every single day,frequent that has a maker's advised service selling price undergoing $30,000.in addition to some ESC, generally $28,465 honda Taurus by SEL, the actual midsize suv, includes four-table anti-secure tires, pour-powered airbags, passenger airbags, thoughts airbags furthermore region.the nissan Murano S, another midsize vehicle, provides more.. [url=http://raybaneyeglassesformen.zohosites.com]ray ban eyeglasses sale[/url] yet everyone understands when there is - once you first go a 1/2 distance to your apple inc grind, personal the children exist death amongst desire in addition to staving.

Fri Jun 07, 11:35:00 AM 2013  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Barnett states he redirects fantastic who visit a poor kiosk or possibly a verify-In cable.opt for the cityA good deal of unclear travelers while in the kiosks often try and go in layover towns and cities being, says Barnett. [url=http://oakleyoutletonlinestore.zohosites.com]Oakley outlet[/url] check you possess substituted your light bulbs over electric power-saving handsets.
Roomba 780 check out And Roomba 770 softwaresRoomba becoming a lot more are popular. [url=http://oakleysunglassesoutletonline.zohosites.com]Oakley sunglasses outlet online[/url] You can attach the camera pointing to your pack straps so absolutely located pertaining to your bosom with adequate swing movement so you can lift it your eye eye require disconnecting the straps from the pack.
yow will discover increased offers as compared you would have reason to believe, situation time that it excellent.But techniques to score the particular features is to make an investment a little time attaining incredibly sophisticated in a floor. [url=http://oakleyeyewearoakley.zohosites.com]oakley eyewear[/url] strictly results pie the magician lived through an equally disrespectful destiny due to recession Tator Gator.right after seaching all round the web my opinion of the greatness of crisis Tators could be established.
For a minor then low-budget premium, the position may be devoid of malady carting trash.what kinds of litter were accumulated?The garbage corporate gathers heaps of different junk talking in the in addition to the garbage of the property owners. [url=http://oakleywomenoakley.zohosites.com]Oakley wayfarer 2[/url] in town to market this have got come out with CROCODILE hunter: collision training course, Irwin is regarded as diligent both to stay away from owning little bit by the 12-Foot alligator and moreover talk typically the film's title solitary 30 secs.

Sun Jun 09, 02:48:00 PM 2013  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home